The Conflict Between EMR Adoption and HIPAA Violation Issues

Methodologyunderlying costs and benefits of EMRs. Responses to
Description of Researchquestions about the EMRs adoption cost and annual
The purpose of this study is to measure and identifymaintenance fees revealed that 7 physicians (32%)
the major benefits and challenges of EMRdo not know the upfront cost of software and
implementation. The objective of the study is tohardware installation as well as ongoing maintenance
describe the existing situation and experiences on thefees. This result indicated clearly that they have
implementation of EMRs across the country. Thisimplemented EMRs through their large medical group
study has employed a significant qualitative approach.organizations that purchased IT for them. However,
It is based on collection of available data in regards to32% of physicians reported that the average cost of
the implementation of EMRs and critical analysis basedEMRs adoption is between $30,000 and $100,000 per
survey results from Family and other specialtiesphysician and annual maintenance fees is between
physicians' perceptions. The method I used will be a$1,000 and $2,000 per physician. In addition, 6
descriptive analysis of published literature and reports,physicians (27%) reported that EMRs adoption cost is
and critical analysis of conducting surveys. Thebelow $30,000 per physician. Lastly, two physicians
research goal is to evaluate the transition from(9%) reported that EMRs cost is about $100,000 per
traditional medical records to a paperless system. It isphysician with more sophisticated and complex
also to determine whether or not this rapid changefeatures. Responses to questions about EMRs
will be co variable and potentially correlate with thebenefits are illustrated in table 1.
impact of using EMRs versus HIPAA violations.Of the 22 who responded to the question whether
Selection of ParticipantsEMRs improves their practice's productivity and
A total of 51 physicians from a variety of specialtiesefficiency, 95% of physicians reported, "Yes". Then,
within small and medium-size medical practices andthey were asked to check benefits of EMRs aspect
varying locations in the Los Angeles and South Baythat apply to their practice. There is a significant
areas in Southern California were chosen tonumber of physicians who believed that electronic
participate in this mail survey.medical records have played a key factor in their
Instrumentationmedical practices' productivity and efficiency as well
The effect of using EMRs and privacy concernsas the quality of care and patient safety and medical
perceived by physicians are measured through anreimbursement, such as: 1) saving their staff's time
administered questionnaire. The quantitativefor looking and filing chart (96%), 2) saving office
measurement including the cost of implementingspace for chart storage (91%), 3) increasing chart
EMRs have been assessed in this survey. In addition,documentation and accuracy for medical
the qualitative measures are used to assess thereimbursement 72%), 4) improving drug refill
physicians' perceptions on how EMRs would benefitcapabilities (72%), 5) reducing medical errors (72%)
them, from improving the quality of care and medicalas well as 6) improving clinical decision-making (72%).
errors to increasing health care efficiency while savingAlso, when asking physicians about how much time it
costs, and their personal attitudes toward this ITwill take them to look up or get a patient's health
network.record electronically within the same practice, 91%
Procedurereported that it takes less than 5 minutes and 10
Fifty one EMRs physician users from differentminutes from an external provider.
locations and medical practices in the South Bay ofResponses to question about the EMRs challenge, a
California were randomly selected to participate in thissignificant number of physicians (45%) reported that
important survey. The assessment of their attitudesthey have faced "none of these issues "with health
toward EMRs' adoption based on the result of theinformation technology. However, of the 22 who
questionnaire tends to be positive. Statistical analysisresponded to the EMRs return on investment, 22%
is performed to correlate the implementation ofof physicians reported that EMRs provides an
EMRs versus the number of HIPAA violations. Thisinsufficient return investment. 4 % of physicians
allows me to examine the positive and negativereported that they have faced "all these above
impact of using EMRs in healthcare industry settings,issues" with EMRs (e.g. the figure above).
and to observe any correlation to the transition.Next, when questioning physicians about the impact
Measures of Questionnaireof EMRs on patient's privacy and confidentiality issues
The questionnaire consisted of 6 parts. The firstusing a 4- point Likert scale, 62% of responders still
section included questions about physician practicestrongly feel that EMRs is secure and safe.
and ownership profile, the number of physicians in theConclusions
practice, volume of patients in a typical day ofThe advantages of implementing of EMR system in
practice, number of employees and ownership type.physician practices settings are obvious, for patients
The second section contained questions about EMRsand health professionals. Ease of access to the health
adoption and type of EMRs using in their practice.information, increased safety and quality of care are
The third section included the cost and maintenancepredominantly positive aspects of EMRs from the
fees of EMRs adoption. The fourth section-containedperspective of patient health as well as from
questions about the benefits of using EMRs inphysicians' perceptions. With our modern electronic
physician practices included multiple-choice questionsworld in healthcare industry, health professionals and
to evaluate specific and potential aspects of EMRs.physicians will gain potentially from the possibility to
The fifth part was asked about the challenges orshare patient's health information network within the
barriers of EMRs, which included multiple-choicesame practice and among external providers.
questions. The last section contained questions aboutElimination of duplication tests, monitoring chronic
patient privacy and confidentiality issues whetherdisease management or adverse drug interactions
EMRs is still secure and physician satisfaction relatedthrough EMRs enhancement will make the healthcare
to EMRs using a 4-point Likert scale ranging fromdelivery system more efficient and cost effective. As
"Strongly agree"(4), "Agree" (3), "Disagree"(2) anda result, the research studies and survey clearly
"Strongly disagree"(1), and similarly to "Verysuggest and confirm that health professionals and
satisfied"(4), "Satisfied" (3), "Dissatisfied" (2) andphysicians perceive that the EMRs are much better
"Very dissatisfied"(1).than paper records because it can enhance patient
Next, I was very interested in measuring thesafety and care.